|
Ballet Idaho: Learning Through Dance
Compiled by Wendy de la Harpe and Dr. Larry Rogien, PhD.
Ballet
Idaho is the premier professional ballet company in the state of
Idaho and a recipient of the 2000
Governor’s Award for Excellence in the Arts and the 2001
Mayors Award for Arts Education. According to Dance USA
(the National Association for Dance
Companies), Ballet Idaho is among the top forty highest
grossing ballet companies in the country. Each year, Ballet Idaho
tours between four and seven states with The Nutcracker,
making our state’s ballet company the fourth largest producer of
The Nutcracker performances just behind New York City Ballet,
Boston Ballet, and San Francisco Ballet. In addition to these
prestigious accomplishments, Ballet Idaho’s Academy is one of only
two schools in the Northwest accredited by the National Association
of Schools of Dance.
All major ballet companies have an education department that is
responsible for educating the public about dance through school
systems, pre- and post-concert talks, informal presentations,
lecture demonstrations and various other creative means. I am the
Director of Education for Ballet Idaho, responsible for overseeing
eight educational outreach programs.1)
Family Series is a pre-performance, abridged production especially
formatted for families with young children. Young children learn the
basics of audience participation and are introduced to professional
ballet .2) Arts Powered Learning Assemblies are presented at schools
throughout Idaho. Eight professional dancers perform a production
designed to tie in to Elementary school curriculum. 3)Dance Advance
is a scholarship program for students selected during the
residencies who demonstrate an aptitude and willingness to commit
to a year of study at Ballet Idaho Academy. 4) Jump Start and New
Visions are two programs presented in partnership with Very Special
Arts of Idaho for children with special needs. 5) Dance Discovery
are public performance or lecture demonstrations for selected
private groups. 6) Ballet Idaho Choreography Competition is a state
wide competition to encourage young pre-professional choreographers
.7) Teacher in Service is held annually in partnership with the
State Department of Education to assist teachers use kinesthetic
leaning in their classrooms. 8) Learning Through Dance, the
flagship program, is a ten- week residency presented by Ballet Idaho
free of charge to Elementary schools.
I have been with Ballet Idaho for five years. I started off as an
Artist-in-Residence in for the Learning Through Dance
program. Previous to my time with Ballet Idaho I have worked as a
dance educator and choreographer in South Africa, London, Los
Angeles, Paris and Portland Oregon.
Ballet Idaho has
partnered with the Idaho State Department of Education and the Idaho
Commission on the Arts for several workshops with local school
districts and teachers, during which the need for arts education and
assistance with kinesthetic learning in academic core curriculum has
been expressed. Ballet Idaho has also worked with the State
Department of Education to develop the State Standards for the
Humanities, specifically Dance. These Standards are addressed at an
annual teacher in-service Ballet Idaho presents in partnership with
the State Department of Education. During the workshops, teachers
have expressed a need for instruction in schools to address these
standards. There are few resident dance teachers at elementary
schools in Idaho and Ballet Idaho is working to fill this need.
In 1997, as a means to bring dance to students and teachers in
elementary schools Ballet Idaho introduced a pilot program to
selected schools in Idaho. Research into arts education determined
that in order to be a desirable arts program for schools, the
program
needed
to be tied to core curriculum and state educational standards. The
curriculum was developed by dance educator Joe Dewey with input from
Charles “Chip” McNeal , Education Manager of San Francisco Ballet.
During the years 2001 and 2002 the curriculum was refined, tested,
written, edited and published by myself, then the Artist in
Residence at Ballet Idaho, Karla Bodnar, then the Director of
Education and education specialist, Lisa Fisher. Dr Peggy Wenner,
Arts and Humanities Specialist at the Idaho State Department of
Education provided a letter of support and funding for the
publishing of the curriculum was provided by the Idaho Commission on
the Arts with assistance from Ruth Piispanen, Director of the Arts
in Education. The completed curriculum was submitted to the Idaho
Department of Education and the National Standard for Arts Education
for endorsement which was received in 2002.
The Learning Through Dance program provides schools with an
Artist-in Residence for ten weeks to work with third grade
students. Typically, the Artist teaches a one-hour lesson to a
class once a week for ten weeks. The Idaho State Standards for third
grade humanities, language arts, mathematics, and the National
Standards of Arts Education have been incorporated into the program,
providing students with a fully integrated learning experience. The
program is designed specifically for third grade, however, most of
the concepts and lessons can be modified for any grade level.
The first lesson opens with the “Self-Control Dance.” This is really
follow-the-leader, but the students are asked to maintain control of
their bodies, as they try to match the instructor’s movements
exactly, and to maintain control of their voices, which should not
be used during the “Self-Control Dance.” The “Self-Control Dance” is
followed by a warm-up, to articulate and stretch the body. Both of
these activities are repeated at the beginning of each lesson. They
become the opening ritual of the dance classes.
The activities that follow these in the first two lessons develop
the students’ spatial and body awareness, as well as continuing to
work without the use of voice. Activities include the “Stop-and-Go
Dance” (students are directed to move while music is playing, and to
freeze when the music stops) and mirroring exercises. Also
introduced is the concept of the Three Levels of Movement (high,
middle, and low). Students are given further practice of use of
space when they learn Stage Directions (stage right, upstage, etc.)
Every lesson concludes with the students running and leaping across
the space. They sometimes create their own jumps and sometimes are
practicing technical skills.
To sharpen memory skills, and introduce historical and cultural
aspects of dance, the students learn a traditional dance, the
“English Country Dance.” In Lesson 5, the memory skills are again
tested as the students learn about theme in choreography as well as
the plight of the endangered Giant Panda with the “Panda Dance.”
These dances are repeated each lesson.
The students also create their own choreography. Students arrange
traditional ballet steps in an order of their choosing, and will
create “sculptures” and actions to represent nouns and verbs.
Students create their own visual symbols and then translate them to
movement in the “Symbol Dance,” which is an introduction to the
“Math Dance.” In the “Math Dance,” students create movement for each
symbol in an arithmetic equation.
We have several options for our science lessons, and often confer
with the classroom teacher to decide which ones to use. We have a
“Solar System Dance” that offers experiences with gravity and
orbiting, as well as the distinguishing characteristics of each
planet. We have a “Map Dance,” that offers experiences in reading,
creating, and following maps. We have a “Body Dance” to address how
various anatomical systems are put together and how they work. We
also have a lesson that addresses the form and function of Simple
Machines, such as levers, inclined planes, and wheels and axels. In
the very recently revamped Idaho Content Standards for Third Grade
Science, there is less emphasis on simple machines and the solar
system, and more on the State of Matter, so we have developed a new
lesson that has the students imitating the movement of molecules
inside solids, liquids, and gases.
The
Learning Through Dance program developed by Ballet Idaho is a
unique outreach program for a ballet company in that the curriculum
is designed to improve academic achievement using dance. Typically
ballet companies will give a class focusing solely on a general
understanding of dance: for example, by giving a beginning dance
class focusing on body positions and traditional dance steps.
Since the inception of Learning Through Dance nine teachers
have been trained to teach the curriculum and have taught over 1000
third grade students annually since 2001. Anecdotal evidence
indicates that children (especially those with English as second
language) learn concepts such as nouns and verbs, gravity, and the
three states of matter more effectively through movement.
Ballet Idaho has received funding from the Idaho Commission on the
Arts, the National Endowment for the Arts and generous local
foundations to continue to offer the programs free of charge to
schools, however, sponsors are now requiring statistical evidence of
the success of arts programs. While arts educators are in agreement
that it is very difficult to quantify results for a subjective art
form, the academic achievement could be quantified. This increasing
need to develop an evaluation tool became a major goal for Ballet
Idaho in order to continue the success and funding of the program.
Fortunately, a chance meeting with a colleague led to the meeting
with Dr. Larry Rogien of Boise State University who agreed to do an
audit of the curriculum and to design a pre- and post-test that
could be used to evaluate the program.
We are very excited by the results of the evaluation of our
Learning Through Dance program by Dr. Larry Rogien, who is a
professor of Educational Psychology at BSU. During the last two
years we have been collecting data via pre- and post-tests based on
the Idaho State Standards for Third Grade as well as National
Standards for Arts. The pre- and post-tests were designed to test
students understanding of dance, level changes, shape, form, spatial
awareness and self-control as well as historical connections and
cultural significance. Language Arts were addressed in lessons and
testing on the structure of a story and use of nouns and verbs.
Testing on science subjects included simple machines, the solar
system, and the three states of matter.
During 2005, Dr. Rogien met with me, and Jennifer
Pierce, a Ballet Idaho Administrative Assistant and BSU graduate, on
a monthly basis to refine and interpret the data being collected. At
the end of June, once all the data had been entered, Dr. Rogien was
able to compute a statistical result which showed a significant
point increase between the pre- and post-tests. The results of the
testing indicate that students who experienced the Learning
Through Dance program improved from a pre-test result to a post-
test result by more than 30 percentile points, using standard
scores.
Significance testing was done using a simple matched pair T-test.
Excel analysis indicates that the difference between pre- and
post-test results was significant (p < 1.66 E-18). The effect size
for the treatment in z score units was 1.28. See table 1 below.
Table 1: t-Test: Paired Two Sample for Means
|
|
|
|
|
|
Variable
1 |
Variable
2 |
|
Mean |
17.6381 |
23.37143 |
|
Variance |
20.19469 |
21.52418 |
|
Observations |
105 |
105 |
|
Pearson
Correlation |
0.282765 |
|
|
Hypothesized Mean Difference |
0 |
|
|
df |
104 |
|
|
t Stat |
-10.7389 |
|
|
P(T<=t)
one-tail |
7.52E-19 |
|
|
t Critical
one-tail |
1.659637 |
|
|
P(T<=t)
two-tail |
1.5E-18 |
|
|
t Critical
two-tail |
1.983037 |
|
|
Effect size
(z units) |
1.275818
|
|
The following are quotes from third grade teachers whose classes
have experienced the Learning Through Dance program:
The
most valuable parts of the program are that all of the lessons so
easily meet
the
standards and curriculum set forth by the state of Idaho. The
creative and
original teaching methods help children tremendously.
Tina
Skinner, third grade teacher at St Joseph’s School, Boise, ID
To me the most valuable thing was how well subjects connected to
things I am teaching
in my
classroom, such as the “verb dance.”
Laura
Labrun, third grade teacher at Iowa Elementary, Nampa, ID
Well-known and respected Dance Educator Anne Green Gilbert of
Seattle, Washington, in her book, Teaching the Three Rs Through
Movement Experience writes, “I first taught third grade in a
north Chicago elementary school. The children were not motivated or
excited about learning. Being a dancer and a dance educator and
realizing the importance and values of non-verbal communication, I
decided to start a movement program in my classroom. The change was
amazing! The scores on their spelling tests greatly improved after
sessions in body spelling. The children took a new interest in math
after making up problems with their bodies. They understood the
revolution of the planets after moving around the classroom in the
solar system they had created.”
Like Anne Green Gilbert, my colleagues and I have witnessed
increased academic achievement by our dance students, but we have
also observed major behavioral changes in students during the
ten-week course. Students become more disciplined and inclined to
follow directions. The Physical Education Specialist at one of the
pilot schools said that he can tell which students in his school in
Nampa have had the ten week Learning Through Dance program
and which have not simply by their level of self-control. A young
student from China who was spending his first day in school in the
United States and did not speak any English was able to participate
in class from the first day and was quickly able to integrate with
the other students in his class since the communication was
non-verbal.
A young boy at a school in Nampa
participated in the dance classes, although he had a physical
difficulty that excluded him from participating in PE. . His teacher
was so amazed that she called his parents to come and observe the
next class. A young boy who had been in a wheelchair for most of his
life was just learning to walk with the use of crutches and leg
braces. He participated eagerly in the classes and found ways to
adapt the choreography to suit his ability. Teachers often remark on
new insight into the way their students think that they gain when
they observe the class. Stereotypical misconceptions about ballet
are broken especially by the boys who find the classes energetic and
fun.
Why use the arts
in education? In a speech on October 12, 2002 at the Boise Center on
the Grove, Dr Elliot Eisner, Professor of Education and Professor of
Art at Stanford University, explained that in answering this
question “reason exceeds what one is able to say” and “cognition
extends beyond language.” Eisner presented reasons the arts are
important to education and suggested the arts teach students the
following eight ideas and concepts:
1) Qualitative relationships matter,
2) How to think with a specific medium,
3) Nuance matters,
4) Form can express feeling,
5) Purposes are best held flexibly,
6) Not everything we know can take the
imprint of language,
7) Imagination and surprise are important,
8) Some activities are self-justifying -
the reward is the journey.
As many of us would agree, our arts experiences are
often some of the most significant ones of our lives, but it is
extremely difficult to explain why. The arts can teach us about
ourselves, other people, other cultures, and other ideas. The arts
aid us in seeing things in an entirely new way. The arts show us how
to be flexible with our minds and hearts so that we can deal with
problems and conflicts with agility and finesse. The arts display
the power of human dedication, both in technical accomplishment and
in compassion. As schools are becoming more and more responsible for
not only the “book-learning” of children, but the development of
their character as well, it seems the arts must be present. The arts
provide explanation, creativity, problem-solving, and perhaps, most
importantly, inspiration.
So, while we celebrate our wonderful test scores, we do
know that we are affecting our young students in so many other
positive ways as well. We are confident, that in many ways, our
students are Learning Through Dance.
Related Reading
Eisner, Elliot: Educational
Imagination: On the Design and Evaluation of School Programs.
Prentice Hall, 2001.
Consortium of National Arts Education Associations: National
Standards for Arts Education: What Every Young American Should Know
and Be Able to Do in the Arts, 1994.
Gilbert, Anne Green: Teaching the Three
Rs Through Movement Experiences: A Handbook for Teachers. The
University of Washington. Seattle, Washington, 1977.
Idaho Content Standards can be found at:
http://www.sde.idaho.gov/instruct/standards/
Ballet Idaho Learning Through Dance
School Residency Program Schedule
Lesson One Introduction; The Physical
Conversation, Spatial and Musical
Awareness and Relationships,
Level Changes, The Mirror dance
Lesson Two The Three Types of Dance, Marching
Band Moves, English
Country Dance, Stage Direction,
Mirroring with a Partner
Lesson Three History of Ballet, Introduction to
Ballet Steps and Positions, The
Five Movement Qualities with
Changing Levels and Tempi,
Choreography and Creativity
The
classes above prepare students for the program, explaining the
Artists expectations and defining a method of working with
students whom have never participated in a dance class
Lesson Four Language Arts: Verbs-The Action Dance
Lesson Five Language Arts: Nouns and Themes -
Panda Dance
Lesson Six Language Arts: Creative Writing –
The Panda Dance Part 2 (Class
teacher needs to prepare a story)
Lesson Seven Mathematics: Symbols- The Movement
Symbol Dance (Class teacher needs to supply
paper and crayons)
Lesson Eight Mathematics: The Math dance (Class
teacher need to supply paper and crayons)
Lesson Nine Science : Simple Machines-
The Mechanism Dance (Option A) Science: Geography – The Map Dance
(Option B)
Lesson Ten Science: Anatomy – The Body Dance
(Option A) Science: Solar System-
The Solar System Dance (Option B) Science: The Three States of
Matter – The Molecule Dance (Option C)
Thirty two students will be selected from participating schools to
receive a full scholarship to the Ballet Idaho Academy of Dance.
Scholarship recipients for all schools will be announced in late
spring.
|